Author(s): Glynda A. Hull, Amy Stornaiuolo
Year of publication: 2014
Keywords: Cosmopolitanism, Youth engagement, Intercultural dialogue, Design-based research, Proper distance, Reflexivity, Multimodal composition
Methodology/Sample: Mixed-methods design-based research study/25 students
Reference: Hull, G. A., & Stornaiuolo, A. (2014). Cosmopolitan literacies, social networks, and “proper distance”: Striving to understand in a global world. Curriculum Inquiry, 44(1), 15-44. https://doi.org/10.1111/curi.12035
Abstract
How are identities as cosmopolitan citizens realized in practice, and how can dialogue be fostered across differences in culture, language, ideology, and geography? More particularly, how might young people be positioned to develop effective and ethical responses, in our digital age, to local and global concerns? Such are the questions we addressed in a design‐based research project that linked young people around the world via a private social network. In effect, we studied cosmopolitanism “on the ground,” as youth on the cusp of adulthood came to think and act reflexively about the opportunities, responsibilities, and challenges of intercultural, cross‐geographic communication in a global, digital world. To analyze the conversations and creative artifacts exchanged by groups of youth in New York City and in India, we invoked the cosmopolitan construct of “proper distance,” asking how participants gauged their relationship to their readers. We identified three stances that composers adopted in their efforts to communicate with and understand their audiences—proximal, reflexive, and reciprocal—and we demonstrated how such stances were manifested semiotically and relationally. This study contributes to a growing literature on the relationship of globalization to education and on cosmopolitanism as one response to this confluence. It demonstrates in empirical, interactional detail the complexity and challenge of learning to communicate, create, and understand across difference, as well as the potential of youth to engage those complexities ethically and to work at comprehending their subtleties. It further illuminates the centrality, for our youthful participants and their cosmopolitan project, of being able to compose in multiple and conjoined modes, and it reanimates the rhetorical construct of “audience” for digital and global times.
> Summary
- The paper explores how cosmopolitan identities are realized through dialogue across cultural differences in a digital age.
- It examines the relationship between youth communication and ethical responses to local and global issues.
- The study analyzes youth interactions in New York and India, focusing on their understanding of audience and proper distance.
- It identifies three stances—proximal, reflexive, and reciprocal—adopted by composers in their communication efforts.
- The research contributes to literature on globalization and education, emphasizing the importance of multimodal composition.
> Problem statement
- The paper explores how cosmopolitan identities are realized and how dialogue can be fostered across cultural and geographical differences.
- It addresses the challenges young people face in developing ethical responses to local and global concerns in a digital age.
- The research investigates the complexities of communication and understanding across differences, particularly among youth in New York and India.
- It highlights the need for proper distance in understanding others’ experiences and the failures in communication that arise from misinterpretations.
- The study emphasizes the importance of recognizing and engaging with the Other in their sameness and difference.
> Methods used
- A mixed-methods design-based research study was conducted, creating a private social network called Space2Cre8 (S2C8) for youth communication.
- Data were collected through online participation analytics and ethnographic observations of youth’s offline practices.
- The study involved multiple rounds of open-ended and thematic coding using qualitative data analysis software.
- Ethnographic data included field notes, audio/video recordings, and interviews to understand youth’s digital and offline interactions.
- The analysis focused on triangulating multiple data sources and identifying audience-sensitive textual strategies.
- The research examined how youth navigated semiotic systems and engaged with diverse audiences.
- The study aimed to explore ethical dimensions of author and audience roles in digital communication.
- The abstract highlights the project’s focus on fostering dialogue across cultural differences through a private social network.
> Practical implications
- The paper explores how young people can develop effective and ethical responses to global concerns through dialogue across cultural differences.
- It emphasizes the importance of understanding audience relationships in digital communication.
- The research highlights the potential for youth to engage ethically in intercultural communication.
- It suggests that cosmopolitan literacies can foster empathy and toleration among diverse groups.
- The findings can inform educational practices that promote critical pedagogy and women’s empowerment.
- The study illustrates the complexities of learning to communicate across differences, enhancing educational frameworks.

Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.